In line with previous studies looking into the relationship between vaping and smoking, an earlier review also conducted by Australian researchers had debunked the infamous Gateway Theory. Titled, “Does the gateway theory justify a ban on nicotine vaping in Australia?,” this earlier review was conducted by renowned THR expert Colin Mendelsohn and Wayne Hall.
The authors had explained that a more plausible explanation as to why young people who vape are more likely to smoke, are personality factors. This means that those teens who vape are risk-takers and are therefore also more likely to smoke, drink alcohol, use cannabis and other substances, as well have unprotected sex. This argument has already been emphasized by other experts in multiple studies.
The Key findings from the present study were as follows:
- “Smoking usually precedes vaping. At least 70-85% of teen smokers try vaping after having already started smoking.
- Most vaping by adolescents is experimental and infrequent
- Regular vaping is rare among non-smokers. Regular vaping by non-smokers is generally 1% or less in Australian and international surveys.
- Many adolescent vapers use flavourings only and do not use nicotine. Nicotine addiction is rare in vapers who don’t smoke. In the US, <4% of non-smoking youth who vape have symptoms of nicotine dependence.
- Some adolescents use vaping to quit smoking
- Youth smoking rates have declined rapidly in the UK and US since the introduction of vaping, making it very unlikely that is increasing youth smoking. It is more likely that vaping is diverting some high-risk teens away from smoking to a safer alternative”
Regurgitating a flawed theory
Countries which have endorsed the use of e-cigs for smoking cessation, such as the UK, have low smoking rates and no teen vaping issues.
Sadly, a recent review led by the Australian National University’s national centre for epidemiology has ignored these findings. The researchers looked into 25 research studies on e-cigarette use and smoking uptake from across the globe, and given the aforementioned relationship between vaping and smoking, concluded that e-cigarettes are a gateway to smoking.
“This review found consistent evidence that use of e-cigarettes, largely nicotine-delivering, is associated with increased risk of subsequent combustible smoking initiation, current combustible smoking and smoking relapse after accounting for known demographic, psychosocial and behavioural risk factors,” they concluded.
Lead study author Prof Emily Banks, said that a common pattern was observed whence those who used e-cigarettes being more likely to take up smoking than those who did not. “In some places smoking is common and in Australia, it is much more uncommon, and we are now at the point where 97% of teenagers have never smoked,” said Banks.
“We don’t want to jeopardise that incredibly strong position Australia is in by introducing something that might increase the probability that they might smoke, and pick up a very deadly habit.”
Countries which endrosed e-cigs have no teen vaping issues
A recent study from the US, “Smoking Intention and Progression From E-Cigarette Use to Cigarette Smoking,” has similarly concluded that e-cig use was associated with increased odds of smoking, among adolescents who had no previous smoking intention.
“Research is showing us that adolescent e-cigarette users who progress to cigarette smoking are not simply those who would have ended up smoking cigarettes anyway,” says lead study author Olusegun Owotomo in a press release. “Our study shows that e-cigarettes can predispose adolescents to cigarette smoking, even when they have no prior intentions to do so.”
Meanwhile, proving the arguments in favour of vaping, countries which have endorsed the use of e-cigs for smoking cessation, such as the UK, have low smoking rates and no teen vaping issues. On the other hand, in Australia where vaping products can only be only obtained via prescription, smoking rates remain alarmingly high, and little progress is being made in decreasing them.
More Data dispell the Gateway Theory
Moreover, recent data from the US has indicated a rapid decline in teen smoking rates corresponding with the increase in vaping uptake. A research team from the University of Michigan analyzed nationwide data on tobacco product use among 8th, 10th and 12th-graders from 1991 to 2019. The compiled data indicated a sharp drop in smoking, consistent amongst all sub-groups, corresponding to an increase in vaping rates amongst the same groups.
Study author Rafael Meza emphasized that clearly the “Gateway Theory” holds no ground. “So I think the good news is that the rapid increase in e-cigarette use has not yet resulted in a reversal of the decreasing trends of cigarette smoking and smokeless tobacco use, and if anything, those trends have accelerated.”
Read Further: The Guardian
‘Gateway theory’ detrimental to public health
Let’s block ads! (Why?)